I’ve got one switch that’s in a 6-switch multi-way setup (7-way? No idea what to call it at this point - Mostly the previous house owner’s obsession about being able to turn off outside lights from anywhere in the house). Wired using dumb toggles, and the Blue series in the line box, with a neutral.
In one “configuration” of all the dumb switches, the Blue series works fine at the switch, on and off work as expected.
In the other “configuration” of the dumb switches, the blue series always reports “on”, regardless of the actual load state . If you try and turn it off at the blue series, the relay clicks, and the status LED goes dim for a short bit (less than a second), then turns back on. The load actually switches though (if it was on, it’s now off, if it was off, it’s now on).
Going on vacation for the next few days, but I’ll try that when I get back.
Not sure how that would cause issues though - Why would it work right in one configuration, but not the other. (Like when the lights are on the load terminal its OK, but when they’re on the traveler terminal they’re not? I’m not sure which terminal works right, and which one is wrong, could be the other way around) - Maybe some weird parasitic load with the motion fixtures combined with some difference in the 2 terminals on the switch?
Yeah, it could be a lot of things. I understand what you’re saying about one terminal or the other, but a smart switch is more complex. One thing we’d see with the Reds is that they won’t work in multi-ways with lighted dumb switches. I can’t explain technically why that’s the case, I just know that it is.
So I’m thinking that the motion sensor may be the same sort of outlier. But this is just a guess on my part.
(Background: I’m an electronics / firmware engineer for my day job)
The lighted 3-way switches cause issues because they draw some power, even when the end light isn’t connected - Essentially the switch can’t tell the difference between the 3-way drawing power and a low wattage LED.
The motions here I wouldn’t expect to cause problems, since they’re completely disconnected when the loads are off, but who knows what weird behavior they cause on the load side, so it’s definitely a good diagnostic step - Essentially eliminate anything weird in the setup.
I may also try just dropping another blue series in place here (or even a red, I think I’ve got one spare) to see if they have similar issues.
Finally got around to pulling the motion fixtures off the circuit, and no change in the behavior. One orientation of the dumb 3/4-way switches means the blue series always thinks its on, the other orientation works correctly.
Total wire length here is really long (120+ ft of traveller, plus another maybe 80 ft from the last 3-way to the lights), maybe some issue with capacitance / inductance on the traveler + load pair?
I’m going to swap in another blue series today, see if that makes any difference, but it seems like there’s some weird measurement going on here.
Another follow up here: Same behavior even with no load devices. Motion fixtures removed from the circuit, and the 2 LED flood bulbs unscrewed. One orientation of the 3/4-way switches is wonky, and the other one is fine.
Shortening the circuit by removing the last switch in the line, and about ~40ft of both traveler and load wiring (Which ran through an underground conduit), and everything’s happy now.
I’m going to keep it in this configuration for now, but it would be good if Inovelli could support long runs like this. Probably something with capacitance on the long ass lines, might need some delays or peak-sensing on the current trip.